RIP ALIAS, 9/30/01 – 1/26/03 (?)
May 31st, 2005 3:07 pm by Kelly GarbatoFamous last words, indeed – but maybe for a different reason?
As promised, I watched the last two Alias episodes over the weekend, and here’s my critique…it’s far from “scathing,” though. Quite the contrary – I have to say that the last two eps of Season 4 were the best I’ve seen in more than two years!
I’ve been a huge (HUGE!) Alias fan since the premier of the show back in the fall of 2001. I honestly thought (think!) it was the best thing to come along on network TV (hell, even cable TV) since the X-Files. Tons of action, lots of plot twists, great costumes – and a kick-ass female lead! I never missed a show. Back when it first started, I worked Saturday nights, from about 10 PM until 10 AM the next morning. I’d go home, pass out for about 8 hours, and drag my ass out of bed long enough to heat a frozen pizza and watch Syd in action. Now that’s love, no?
Then they killed it. Yup, I’m referring to the Super Bowl ep. Now, I didn’t care that they flaunted Jennifer Garner around in two shades of Victoria’s Secret to the tune of Back in Black. I didn’t even bat an eye – they could put her in an undercover lesbian threesome, and I wouldn’t care, as long as it’s somehow related to the plot. Heck, I understand their need for ratings, and if slutting up Garner is what it takes to ensure another season, then more power to ‘em!
The last 10 minutes of “Phase One” is what did the show in. For those of you who are unfamiliar, let me recap: the CIA brings down the Alliance and all their SD cells (including Syd’s SD-6), and Syd and Vaughn “see each other amidst the carnage and kiss passionately!” Ugh.
So what’s the problem? Well, for one, the writers basically ended the show. The whole plot centered around Sydney working as a double agent for the CIA in order to foil the Alliance. Now that SD-6 is no more…they have no plot.
And any novice screenwriter knows that you never have your male and female leads get together! The sexual tension between Syd and Vaughn, coupled with the fact that they could never hook up, was a driving force behind the show. Now that they’re together, we’ve lost that “will they or won’t they!?” anticipation. Who wants to see them settle into domestic bliss? How boring!
The Alias writers should have taken a clue from Chris Carter here: he’s the ultimate cock tease. For nine seasons, he managed to string us along with Scully and Mulder. Every time it seemed like they would finally cave in to their carnal desires, Carter threw some kind of wrench into their bed: Mulder isn’t really Mulder, he’s Morris Fletcher in Mulder’s body; Mulder smooches Scully’s 1939 counterpart and promptly gets a right hook to the kisser; Mulder and Scully embrace in the hallway but are interrupted by bees. I mean, c’mon, once Syd and Vaugh shack up, we’ve got nothing to look forward to there – at least wait until the show’s cancelled to give us what we want (because one we’ve got it, what’s the point in coming back every week?).
I’m guessing that Abrams & co. realized their mistake, and this was the driving force behind the Season 2 cliffhanger and the introduction of the gawd-awful Lauren Reed in Season 3. I suppose the show still could have survived had they developed a decent new plotline, but Season 3 was just horrid. ‘Nuff said.
Sans Melissa George, Season 4 wasn’t quite as bad as Season 3, but neither was it anything to get excited about. For starters, there was very little Irina, and even less Sark – by far the finest baddies of the series. They killed off Lauren, which was a plus, but then they introduced the only slightly less annoying half-sister Nadia. Then there were the inconceivable plot lines – do we really think the CIA would be brain-dead enough to not only hire Sloan, but then put him in charge of his own team, with little oversight? (No wonder we can’t find Osama!) Jack is exposed to massive amounts of radiation, which alters his genetic makeup and sends him into fits of delusions, and yet he’s magically healed a few episodes later? (Bet the folks over at Chernobyl could use a visit from Dr. Liddell!) Even Season 9 of the X-Files wasn’t this bad!
Back on May 4, 2003 – the end of Season 2 – I told myself that I’d watch the first few eps of Season 3 before giving up on the show totally. If they sucked, I thought, I should just end it – better than watching the show I loved die a slow, painful death. Of course, it was awful, worse than I’d feared, but I couldn’t let go. I said the same thing about Season 4, and as bad as it was, I kept watching. Last week Shane & I agreed that if the season finale didn’t deliver, we weren’t going to watch it next season. I mean, Season 1, he got a kick in the nuts if he so much as coughed while the show was on. Now, I pause it on a regular basis to heckle the plotlines.
So I was stunned – I mean, jaw-to-the-floor, tongue-rolling-out, straight-up shocked – when “Search & Rescue” and “Before the Flood” actually did deliver. What can I say? They managed to explain Irina’s death and subsequent resurrection in a totally logical and reasonable way. Jack smiled – not once, but twice – and we were treated to a few minutes of nostalgic humor between Jack and Vaughn. Sloane’s back in jail, and Nadia’s a flesh-eating zombie. My only complaint is that they killed off Elena and spared Nadia. Oh, yeah, and still no Sark!
Looks like there’s hope for Season 5 after all. The cheesy twist with Vaughn’s “secret” doesn’t bode well, nor does Nadia’s unlikely survival (after being injected with zombification fluid and then shot at close range by her own father, mind you), but there is hope yet. If only they had the sense to move the show to HBO and bring Chris Carter on board. If only.
- K
Originally posted @ www.kellygarbato.com/blog/2005-05-31/
Filed under: Entertainment — Kelly @ May 31, 2005 3:07 pm
















